Some of the most chilling tales of hauntings in West Virginia are based on real events, and one of the most horrific is that of the Screaming Lady of Mason County. Her ghost is said to haunt, or to have haunted, the woods south of "the Bend" in the Ohio River, as the region is known.
Chris Rizer, president of the Mason County Historical & Preservation Society, accompanied me on a tour of the Bend, the "Big Woods" and the idyllic patch of Amish farms in which the tragedy and haunting are associated.
Driving west from Hartford City through the well-tended farms for which Mason County is known, Rizer recited the tale in a way that seemed oddly coincident with the dimming of the evening. By the time we reached the wood, dusk had begun to gather in the shade beneath the trees.
"Okay, stop. Here's where it happens—or at least here is where people say they hear things," Rizer said as we neared the top of a wooded hill where the woods grew particularly dark.
Only a few months before, he had published a story about the haunting in the Point Pleasant Register, to which he regularly submits features regarding local history. With his permission, I've reprinted an emended selection from that feature here to ensure I'm hitting the high points of the tale.
"More than 150 years ago," Rizer writes, "this area was a pocket of farmland surrounded on all four sides by thick forest known as the Big Woods. That was changing, though, in 1850 as the coal mines and salt furnaces of the Bend sought out lumber for their mills and attracted laborers from the country farms. The mills, looking for old-growth forest, worked their way out from Hartford, Mason, and Clifton, and clear cut enormous tracts of countryside.
"The lumber operations by themselves required a small army of laborers, and the clear-cutting provided an easy route from Gibbstown to Clifton, Mason, or Hartford. In just a few years, this little pocket of farmland had gone from being pretty much the middle of nowhere to a major crossroads between the four towns. This is where our story begins.
"One of the farmers here was David Somerville, who lived a fairly ordinary life with his wife Catherine and their eight children. The two older boys, William and Weston, were laborers, possibly at one of the lumber mills. The two younger boys, John and David, along with daughters Rebecca, Mary, Catherine, and Martha, helped their parents on the farm.
"One night, Mary was the only one home. Perhaps the rest of the family had gone to town or were visiting nearby relatives. In any case, Mary was left home alone.
"As the legend goes, a group of men was passing the farm that night. Maybe they were lumberjacks returning to town, maybe they were laborers returning home. We may never know. They saw that Mary was alone, broke into the cabin, assaulted her, then took her deep into the woods and buried her alive.
"Though Mary was obviously missing, the crime was never discovered. Her family left Mason County not long after and resettled in Indiana, but Mary remained, in more ways than one, some say.
"Not long after the family's departure, farmers and woodsmen began to report hearing a woman’s screams coming from the Big Woods at night. Some Irish immigrants feared they had brought a banshee with them, though the reports had started before they arrived. Not knowing about Mary Somerville, they simply called her 'the Screaming Lady.'
For more than a hundred years, the ghost haunted the Big Woods. More often than not, it was heard rather than seen. Screams with what seemed like no source echoed through the woods.
"One night a newcomer to the area heard the screams. Thinking that a living woman was in trouble, he did what any sane person would do and called the police. Several officers came out and found the source of the screaming—a ghostly woman standing in the road with her face scratched and bloody. They did what most sane people would do. They turned the car around and got the heck out of there, though her screams followed them all the way to town.
"Finally, in 1986, Mary Somerville’s grave was discovered by strip miners who were working on the edge of the Big Woods. Mining stopped, and undertakers from Foglesong Funeral Home were called in to exhume the remains and give them a proper burial at the Zuspan Cemetery. I like to think that since then, the Screaming Lady has been at rest."
Couple claims to photograph bigfoot near New River Gorge
A husband and wife living in a remote corner of Fayette County in southern West Virginia claim to have encountered and photographed a bigfoot. Billy Humphrey, of Danese, says that before the October 2019 incident he had ridiculed such claims but has spent the last half-year turning the encounter over in his mind. Read the full story here.
Sign up to receive a FREE copy of West Virginia Explorer Magazine in your email weekly. Sign me up!